top of page
Blog: Blog2

Beyond the Patch: How Indigenous Cultures Cultivated the First Pumpkins

1 hour ago
4 min read

By Maeve Kiley


The Past of Pumpkins


In the United States, an estimated 1.3 to 1.5 billion pumpkins are sold every year for Halloween. Illinois leads the nation in pumpkin production; annually producing 500 million pumpkins. Pumpkin patches, pumpkin recipes, jack-o-lantern carvers, and pumpkin costumes are staples of the season. Pumpkin spice sits in every drink and canned pumpkin is placed in the front of every grocery store.

Types of pumpkins (squash)
A variety of squash & pumpkins

However, pumpkins are not just Halloween delicacies and porch decorations. Pumpkins are a part of a rich history, intertwined with the Indigenous peoples of North America. Over generations, Indigenous farmers transformed the tough, bitter ancestors of pumpkins into rich, delicious vegetables with nutrient-rich benefits. 


9,000 Years of Harvest


Wild squashes originated in North and Central America with the earliest known documentation of the plant dating back to 7,000 to 5,500 BCE in Oaxaca, Mexico. This ancestor was known as Cucurbita pepo. Unlike the round, orange pumpkins of today, this gourd was small, green, and bitter. 


They were originally eaten and dispersed by Ice Age megafauna, such as Wooly Mammoths. It is theorized that these plants were toxic to deter small herbivores from eating them. When these animals went extinct about 10,000 years ago, the gourds lost their primary means of seed dispersal. It seemed like the end for the Cucurbita pepo, but luckily, intervention came before the population completely crashed. 


Indigenous farmers began a process of selective breeding. They purposefully selected the less-bitter gourds and grew their seeds. In the meantime, the gourds were hollowed-out and used as jars, bowls, and storage vessels. Over generations, this breeding resulted in sweet, large pumpkins that could be roasted, stewed, or steamed while the outer shells were repurposed into flotation devices for fishing devices. 


The Three Sisters Ecosystem


Two of the three sisters (corn and beans)
Beans growing on cornstalks. Squash or pumpkins are not visible yet.

The pumpkins spread across North America. Many tribes harvested pumpkins alongside corn and beans. These vegetables would be combined into the famous polyculture system known as the Three Sisters. In this system, the vegetables mutualistically supported each other by naturally enriching the soil and shading neighboring plants. In this system, the corn provided natural trellis for the beans, the beans pulled nitrog

en from the air to fertilize the soil, and the pumpkin leaves carpeted the ground and trapped moisture inside. 


This system was instrumental in tribal survival during the cold winters. Sophisticated preservation methods were crafted and pumpkins were chopped into long, thin strips and then dried in the sun to create nutrient-rich “pumpkin jerky.” The strips that dried too harshly were woven into mats to keep food mold-free. The pumpkin sap was boiled into medicine to treat harsh burns. The nutrients inside the sap soothed irritation and promoted wound closure.

No part of the pumpkin was wasted, not even the

vines which were made into heat-resistant pot lids. 


Introduction to the West


Spanish and other European colonists first encountered pumpkins in the 15th and 16th century where they called them calabaza, a Spanish word used for gourds native to Spain. The pumpkins were brought to Europe, where they were viewed as peasant food or animal fodder and sold for cheap. 


New England colonists relied heavily on pumpkins. They learned to utilize pumpkins from the Wampanoag tribe who instructed them to preserve pumpkins for the winter. Pumpkins were baked into custards, stewed in soups, and even added to beers. A famous 1630s colonial ballad emphasizes the dependency on pumpkins, “We have pumpkins at morning and pumpkins at noon, If it were not for pumpkins, we would be undoon.” Listen to it below (#5: New England Annoyances @ 1:45 mark).


"New England's Annoyances," a 1630s ballad sings about the importance of pumpkins

The tradition of carving pumpkins is not native to North America. Its origins lie in Ireland, specifically, for Samhain. Scary faces would be carved into turnips and squashes to ward off evil spirits with candles placed inside. When Irish immigrants arrived in the United States in the 1800s, they switched to pumpkins because they were larger, softer, and abundant. The term “Jack-o-Lantern” first appeared in print around 1837 with its connection to Halloween solidified that century. 


Sustainable Farming


In an age of industrialization, it is important to reflect on historical agricultural practices and learn from their example. The Three Sisters model promotes mutualism, sustainability, and wastefree growth. Vegetables are not just viewed as food, they are models of human society and lessons in cooperation. The benefits of environmental stewardship are not just limited to food sources, but communal and global health. 


The story of pumpkins is a tale of relationships. When one carves a pumpkin or enjoys a slice of pumpkin bread, they are participating in a generational legacy. Long before European colonists arrived on ships, Indigenous farmers cultivated harsh, bitter gourds into round, delicious pumpkins in a strategic and sustainable way. Recognizing the historical and cultural significance of pumpkins is to recognize the deep ecological knowledge of traditional Native farming.



The next time a squash or pumpkin plant flowers, visit it shortly after sunrise. Look inside the blossoms for

small, fuzzy bees carrying yellow pollen. Then consider what might be happening beneath your feet.

A garden can support squash bees by maintaining flowering host plants, reducing pesticide use, and leaving

suitable nesting soil undisturbed.


The story of the pumpkin is not simply one of domestication. It reveals how Indigenous agriculture helped

shape relationships among plants, insects, and people across a continent.


The pumpkin may be gone from the vine, but its story is still alive beneath the soil. We'll tell you more about

squash bees in the next article!


References:


Carnegie Museum of Natural History. (n.d.). https://carnegiemnh.org/the-jack-o-lanterns-origins/


Foods indigenous to the Western Hemisphere. American Indian Health - Health. (n.d.). https://aihd.ku.edu/foods/pumpkins.html


IndigenousClimateHub. (2023, June 21). The Three sisters as indigenous sustainable agricultural practice. Indigenous Climate Hub. https://indigenousclimatehub.ca/2023/06/the-three-sisters-as-indigenous-sustainable-agricultural-practice/


Growing Food. Plimoth Patuxet Museums. (n.d.). https://plimoth.org/for-students/homework-help/growing-food


The deep connection between pumpkins and Indigenous people in North America. Autumn Harvest Pumpkins. https://autumnharvestpumpkins.com/blog/the-deep-connection-between-pumpkins-and-indigenous-people-in-north-america/ (2026, September 23). 


Comments


bottom of page